Originally posted by Velo
View Post
2024 Chargers News | Acquisitions | Transactions | Injuries
Collapse
This is a sticky topic.
X
X
-
I'd be stunned if they sign MVS. He had Mahomes and Rodgers for QBs and his career catch rate is 50.3% . We don't need that MFer.
That Tweet has to be old. We need an Edge to challenge Rumph s d Farmer isn't that guy,.... and a maybe a FS
-
👍 2
- Top
- Bottom
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by Boltjolt View PostI'd be stunned if they sign MVS. He had Mahomes and Rodgers for QBs and his career catch rate is 50.3% . We don't need that MFer.
That Tweet has to be old. We need an Edge to challenge Rumph s d Farmer isn't that guy,.... and a maybe a FS
Id be really surprised if they traded Palmer.
But, this is a new FO so who the F knows how they value these guys.
- Top
- Bottom
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by Velo View Post
Cherry-picking stats. JP only played in 10 games in 2023. As a rookie JP had a 67% catch rate and scored 4 TDs, which you conveniently leave out. QJ had a 56.7% catch rated and scored 2 TDs. I don't care what the official stats say, the video evidence of QJ's rookie season shows him making one egregious drop after another, Palmer never has been that bad.
I agree his year 1 fell short, everyone does. I just have not written off that he will develop - year 2 will tell us a lot. I think he will and you’re wrong. Obviously.
You don’t have to care about official stats, you can post what you ‘feel’, I’ll post facts, you can the claim facts don’t exist, then say the facts are wrong, then conclude truth is a lie and only your ‘truth’ is true, we’ll just go round and round like that … fun times.
Peace …“Less is more? NO NO NO - MORE is MORE!”
- Top
- Bottom
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by dmac_bolt View Post
I’m not cherry picking, you said production so I posted production stats. There is no algorithm you can apply to their stats and arrive at JP has 10x production of QJ. You’re not just not cherry picking, you’re pretending there is no orchard and denying there are any cherries at all. JP had a great 2nd year. I like JP. He is what he is but he contributes. His rookie year he produced a lot less receptions and a lot less yards. QJ has not played his second year yet, I suspect your emotional response is subconsciously comparing JP’s second year to QJ’s first. That is a premature cosmic eternal assessment but you don’t care cuz gosh darnit Q disappointed you, he let you down, he did not meet your expectation for yr1. He dropped a pass against GB that made the difference!!!
I agree his year 1 fell short, everyone does. I just have not written off that he will develop - year 2 will tell us a lot. I think he will and you’re wrong. Obviously.
You don’t have to care about official stats, you can post what you ‘feel’, I’ll post facts, you can the claim facts don’t exist, then say the facts are wrong, then conclude truth is a lie and only your ‘truth’ is true, we’ll just go round and round like that … fun times.
Peace …
-
👍 1
- Top
- Bottom
Comment
-
Comment